Next Level Hydrodynamics
Advanced Towing Tank Testing
Time for an upgrade! The towing tank started with basic resistance and speed predictions, but as ship science advanced, our use of the towing tank also expanded. New gadgets and advanced capabilities. Far beyond the single purpose testing facility, the modern towing tank expanded into a Swiss Army knife of experiments, pushing the boundaries of confidence for naval architecture. Time to see what new tricks the old tank holds for us.
2.0 What is a Towing Tank?
Towing tanks are experimental facilities, used to test models of ships. Start by imagining a bathtub, and now scale that up to a giant basin of water several hundred meters long, deeper than a person, and wide as a car. Next dump a LOT of bromine into the water so that algae doesn’t grow. (safety warning: you do not want to swim in a towing tank.) Place that basin inside a climate controlled building. We need this because the experiments are so sensitive that even a 0.3° C change in water temperature affects the readings.
Next add the towing carriage, which is a large movable platform that stretches across the basin of water. (Figure 2‑1) Think of it as a moving laboratory that runs on rails. We tow the ship models from the carriage, but the scientists also ride on the carriage. All the sensors to record the experiment feed to computers mounted on the carriage. And these are no ordinary sensors. Everything in a towing tank demands accuracy and precision. All focused on one goal: obtaining accurate measurements from the ship model as we tow it down a basin of water.
3.0 Advanced Towing Tank Tests
The towing tank started with basic resistance and speed predictions, but as ship science advanced, our use of the towing tank also expanded. The humble towing tank now includes advanced tests for the discerning naval architect.
3.1 Seakeeping Test
The first advancement added waves to the towing tank. (Figure 3‑1) Wave generators create specific combinations of waves, which combine with the model traveling down the tank. This allows us to test the ship response to bow waves. We calculate the average increase in resistance due to waves. Most important to passenger comfort, we also measure the acceleration and magnitude of the ship’s heave and pitch. These measurements become critical for preventing seasickness.
Figure 3‑1: Example of Wave Generator 
The beauty behind this system is generalization. Measurements for a single wave system don’t do much good. What are the odds that you will encounter that exact combination of waves on the open ocean? Instead, designers use the towing tank measurements to generate a generic profile for the ship’s response to any wave system. Those measurements now work for anything from a gentle ripple to monster waves, but they still represent customized measurements for our specific ship.
Unfortunately, towing tanks only work for bow waves. That limitation comes from the dimensions of the towing tank; the tanks are long and narrow. We would need to turn the model sideways for beam waves or quartering waves. But if we turn the model sideways, we block the passage of the waves between the model and the sides of the tank. This blockage effect alters the wave physics and distorts the measurements.
Fortunately, bow waves happen to be relevant to many ship operators. In large storms, you point the ship’s bow into the waves. This is why most towing tanks come equipped with wave generators.
3.2 Maneuvering Coefficients Test
Towing tanks also added a maneuvering coefficients test. Imagine you designed a new submarine or warship, and you needed to guarantee precise maneuvering capability. To achieve that, you need the full maneuvering coefficients for the hull. These coefficients relate the force required for each motion of the hull. For example: you require 50 t-m to turn in yaw at 5 deg/s. And another 30 t-m to accelerate in yaw at 3 deg/s2. We combine those coefficients with some fancy math to determine how much force the rudder needs to generate, leading to a correct design for the rudder size.
Unfortunately, I just picked those numbers at random. To establish real coefficients, we need a maneuvering study.
To achieve the maneuvering study, we add a new gizmo in the towing tank: the planar motion mechanism (PMM). The PMM sways the hull side to side in a snake like motion as the carriage travels down the towing tank. (Figure 3‑2) While this happens, we record the forces that the model exerts on the PMM posts. In simple terms, the side to side motion is the input of our maneuvering motion (actually combining multiple maneuvers into one). And the sensors record the required force to achieve that motion. Add in some math to process the measurements, and we get our maneuvering coefficients.
Figure 3‑2: Planar Motion Mechanism 
3.3 Icebreaking Test
Even icebreakers need somewhere to go. And model scale icebreakers need model scale ice to test on. (Figure 3‑3) Specialized towing tanks include facilities to fabricate ice to the specified thickness and strength for testing. The details change, depending on the full scale ice that you need to mimic in the tank.
The model testing allows designers to record the speed through ice of various thickness, and power required. As you might expect, these facilities are expensive since you need to create new ice after every run. Imagine how long a hockey game would take if they needed to refreeze the ice rink after every play. Something similar happens in the ice tank.
Figure 3‑3: Example of Ice Tank Testing 
4.0 Maneuvering Basin
When the towing tank will not do, we need to add more water! Enter the maneuvering basin. This goes by many names: maneuvering basin, ocean basin, FloWave tank, etc. The maneuvering basin gets around the blockage problem of narrow tanks by building a WIDE and gigantic pool! (Figure 4‑1)
Figure 4‑1: Maneuvering Basin Breakdown 
You find maneuvering basins less commonly than towing tanks, because these mammoths come with a high price. Not just due to the size, but also from all their gadgets:
- Wave makers lining the walls, ready to produce multi-directional wave spectre
- Imagine two wave sets crisscrossing to produce a very complicated pattern . . . and you get real life sea conditions
- Giant fans to simulate ocean wind in the worst hurricane
- Massive underwater propellers to generate underwater currents, which can change direction
- An adjustable tank bottom, to simulate different water depths
Maneuvering basins see most of their work in the offshore industry, testing responses of moored offshore oil rigs, floating assets, or other critical mission operations. Other applications include general seakeeping studies, similar to the towing tank, but now we have the space to check all the wave headings. In recent years, even the offshore wind industry employed the maneuvering basin to simulate the combination of marine waves and offshore wind for floating wind turbines. The common element for all these projects was large budgets and critical mission assets. You go to the maneuvering basin to answer complicated questions, when failure is not an option.
Maneuvering, ice testing, and seakeeping all expanded the towing tank, until we needed even more. For the truly ambitious, nothing will suffice but the all encompassing maneuvering basin. With these expanded test facilities, designers gained the ability to customize and re-imagine new tests to answer many of our modern questions in ship design. Each of these advanced facilities grew to fill new needs from redefining the capabilities of maritime technology. Advanced ship design means advanced testing. So what will we imagine next?
Wikimedia Authors, “Experimental Model Basin, Washington Navy Yard, Washington, DC – interior view, c. 1900. This was the first model basin (towing tank) for the United States Navy.,” Wikimedia Commons, 19 Aug 2007. [Online]. Available: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:US_Experimental_Model_Basin_-_interior_view,_c._1900.jpg. [Accessed 18 Jun 2019].
YouTube Creator: TalTech Meremajanduse keskus, “Small Craft Centre Towing Tank Wave Generator,” YouTube, 1 Mar 2017. [Online]. Available: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3LqRfEKdNdA. [Accessed 18 Jun 2019].
YouTube Creator: froudedude, “FFG 7 Tow Tank Model Test,” YouTube, 8 Dec 2008. [Online]. Available: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iHGGSdGM7Xk. [Accessed 18 Jun 2019].
Defense Media Network, “Scale Icebreaker Breaks Scale Ice,” YouTube, 26 Oct 2017. [Online]. Available: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G18jlFS9BeU. [Accessed 18 Jun 2019].
FloWave Ocean Energy Research Facility, “How FloWave Works Animation,” YouTube, 1 Mar 2015. [Online]. Available: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ePB7PVA42Fs. [Accessed 18 Jun 2019].
J. Carlton, Marine Propellers and Propulsion, London: Butterworth-Heinemann Publications, 2007.
FloWave Ocean Energy Research Facility, “FloWave Exhibition Video 2014,” YouTube, 1 Mar 2015. [Online]. Available: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WffR6HrEqTA. [Accessed 18 Jun 2019].
Want to Learn More?
We can customize each project to meet your goals.
Find the perfect solution for your needs.
Relevant Ship Science Articles
What are the practical steps necessary to execute a stability test? How to avoid the pitfalls? Who do you call to arrange everything? This guide gives advice to the vessel owner on how to prepare for a stability test, from start to finish. Instead of theory, we focus on the logistics and coordination.
Certain as the sea, ships will require stability tests at some point in their life. Or maybe not. This article discusses the different types of stability tests and when regulations require them.
Stability tests do not arrive instantly after you order one. It takes time and planning, and you should expect extensive coordination with several different organizations. But the ultimate benefit justifies the expense: a ship with reliable stability performance. This article unravels some of the mystery behind a stability test and why you want one.
Weight control is not sexy, but the consequences of ignoring it can be very scary. If we ignore weight control, we risk a potentially unusable ship. That is why proper weight control starts with the right attitude: understanding the risks and the necessity of a weight estimate.
Naval architects work daily as systems integrators, but it’s difficult to point to any one system and show where this adds value. So today I want to review some T-AO UNREP equipment, and show how none of this is possible without systems integration.